Pages

Sunday, January 23, 2011

COMM 615 Interpersonal Communication in the Workplace

Interpersonal communication is an exchange between two people where the dyad creates meaning.  Organizations are structured socially to be a system of power. So interpersonal communications at work result in the combination of the two arenas. 

Theory informs workplace communication.  Post-positivist thought lays out that knowledge and understanding occur from investigation and that observation equals reality.  Social construction deals with how meaning is made, through social interaction and communication, and purports that there is no objective truth or “right”. Critical theory looks at socially constructed hierarchical systems and offers a way to analyze interpersonal communications based on control and power.  Structuration theory connects the agent (individual) to the structure (business organization) and shows how the structure of an organization can shape rules and influence communication.  Leader Member Exchange (LMX) theory emphasizes the negotiated nature of supervisor/subordinate relationships where both are active in the process of communication.

In practice, narrative plays an important role in interpersonal communication.  Narrative can be used at work to deal with conflict, can be used to reinforce a collective organizational identity, can increase creativity, and can impact power positions of people within organizations.  Narrative can be used to flesh out subtleties and simplify complexities and can serve to make day-to-day communication more effective.

The five relationships at work are: peer-to-co-worker, workplace friendship, romantic relationships, supervisor/subordinate relationships, and customer/client relationships.  Each relationship has different functions, outcomes and consequences.  These relationships are impacted by issues of depth of relationship, organizational hierarchy, power, and context.

We explored the five interpersonal relationships in a workplace in class and through our reflections by exploring our personal experiences in each of the relational areas.  The real-life applicability of our readings was what made this course come alive. However, I did not feel that I gained new interpersonal skills or was exposed to practical ways to improve various interpersonal relationships.  This course focused on the theory and seemed to dwell on past/present experiences that did more to illustrate the problematic nature of interpersonal relationships at work than to focus on prescriptive ways to make bad situations better.  This was my least favorite class.

COMM 614 Ethics

Life mimics art.  This course was grounded in theory and illuminated by literature and film.

Communication ethics are complex because we live in a postmodern world, an era of disagreement where there is no common understanding of “good”.  There is no single, universal right or wrong.  We found that the “good” is different for each person or group of people. This was mind-opening for me, which I loved!

Communication ethics involves an encounter.  It is a process.  And in an ideal world, it begins with reflection.  First is to understand ourselves and what “good” we are protecting or promoting and why. Because every message is biased, after all, we construct it, it is important to recognize that our content is value-laden and frames information.  We need to consider factors that impact communication ethics: civility, respect and concern for the other, attentiveness to self, other and the historic moment, culture, gender, and care and responsiveness.  In ethical communication, a space open for listening needs to be created if any common ground is to be found.  A commitment to learning, to appreciate “common” senses different from our own can open up possibilities and lead to potential understanding and momentary compromise or resolution. 

We read Les Miserables by Victor Hugo which provided a wealth of examples of communication ethics.  Characters illustrated that being true to their own “good”, which made total “common” sense to them, could create terrible things for others who were pursuing their own separate and different “good”.  Without communication, without a process for listening and understanding another’s perspective, bad things were done in the name of good.  We see that play out today in the news, between friends, and in movies.  

I analyzed two movies, The Constant Gardener (2005) and Good Night, and Good Luck (2005) from a communications ethics perspective.  Viewing a movie from an ethical communications standpoint was a new lens for me, and one which I have found I call on as I watch other movies.  I enjoyed the use of literature and movies as a way of applying communication ethics and taking the abstract and theoretical and moving it to the practical - it was a great learning tool!

The approach to ethics in communication has reinforced my thinking about the ambiguity we live with in most facets of our life today.  This course, more than any other, made me understand post modernism and the theory of social constructionism.  Just as there is no "right" or "wrong" in communication ethics, there is no absolute with anything in our world today.  These premises affect how I view the world, and make me more willing to listen to others, more open to different points of view, more able to see multiple perspectives.  The challenge is to be able to act in the historic moment in spite of the overabundance of perspectives and choices, and to recognize that what works today may differ tomorrow.  Communication with regard and adaptation to/with others as I pursue my personal values with integrity - in the end that's where I wind up in my reflection on communication ethics.

Saturday, January 22, 2011

COMM 612 Persuasion

Persuasion, as defined in the course syllabus, describes the activity required to change a person’s opinion from one position to another using particular strategies.  Persuasion is present in varying degrees and intentions in all communication.

The course offered insights into both the theory and practice of persuasion.  We looked at Aristotle and the components of rhetoric: logos (logic, reasoning), pathos (emotion), ethos (credibility), and mythos (the story or historic place).  This gave a foundation for discourse and helped me understand the separate components involved in communication. 

From the theoretical perspective, I was drawn to the dual process ELM theory.  The ELM Theory describes the two different decision making processors used by the human brain as we make decisions or judgments: the central route (slower, higher level reasoning) and the peripheral route (faster, uses short cuts, icons, brands and preconceptions).  How we think and process information has a clear impact on how persuasive actions can be effective. 

We are impacted by a 24/7 networked world with information and message overload.  We need short cuts, time savers and other mechanisms in order to function and make sense of so much stimuli.  It is in this realm of heuristic decision making that most of the techniques of persuasion come into play. 

Theory applied: individuals can be influenced when needs, emotions, attitudes, and desire for consistency are brought into play. We look for cues, common ground  (likability, identification), we use stories and metaphors to understand and shape complex ideas (which Burke showed can both reveal and conceal), we respond using our expectations and history, we value reciprocation, we respond to both direct and indirect arguments.  We are hard-wired to want things that are scarce. Gladwell in The Tipping Point (2002) shows the importance of special people (Connectors, Mavens and Salesmen), the power of stickiness where packaging counts, the power of one, and the power of context. Cialdini looked at the factors that make people say “yes”.  His book Influence: Science and Practice (2009) explores the power of commitment and consistency, social proof, reciprocity, liking, authority and deference, and explains in layman’s terms the art of persuasion.  I found the practical aspects of persuasion fascinating.

When I graduate from this program, I want to start my own business and act as a consultant helping small business with social media.  In my preparation for this next stage of my life, I was writing notes to myself about my business plan, and got to a point where I felt the need to define social media.  I found in thinking of social media, that this form of communication thrives on:
  • likability
  • credibility/authority
  • social proof
  • scarcity
  • reciprocity
  • consistency
All of the above are also aspects of persuasion!  Businesses, by utilizing social media, are communicating with their stakeholders, their clients and prospects, and are looking to impact or influence them in some way.  Social media can be defined by all of the above motivations of persuasive influence.  Social media can be used to make businesses more accessible, more friendly (likability).  It can be used to enhance business credibility by targeted blogging, useful information sharing and providing forums for two way communication between people and the company.  Social media is all about social proof, just look at the followers section of each social media outlet.   Also, people have a tendency to do business with people who have benefited us in some way (reciprocity and obligation). And finally, we value consistency which, for companies who are doing social media well, is reinforced by careful crafting of image through strategic messaging within the social media platforms.

 So, social media is all about persuasive communication.  Influencing people through communication is what social media and persuasion are about.  Some do it well, others...don't.  Because I now see the direct link between social media and persuasion, I will frame my approach with business in a different way.  More about this in my Capstone project!

The complexity of our world today and our need to process an overwhelming amount of information make the personal use of short cuts in thinking and processing mandatory.  This fact of life opens us up to persuasion, and can impact and influence our behaviors in ways that go against our logical, rational selves. This was my favorite course!

COMM 605 Integrated Strategic Communication: Analysis and Theory

Strategic communications are an organization’s or individual's efforts to lead, motivate, persuade, and inform its various publics. 

In this course we explored a variety of possible theoretical foundations for public relations/strategic communication and found that, while no single theory works to explain this area, a number of theories do apply and are useful in enlightening aspects of the field.

Theorists we studied:  Berger’s social construction of reality informs as it shows the subjectivity of communications and the requirement for agency in the face of pluralism and the crisis of meaning; Giddons adds structuration theory; Goffman’s interpersonal communications theory highlights impression management and the impacts of framing, footing and face on the influence of human agency in strategic communications; Habermas brings theory pertaining to the public sphere, focusing on the importance of public discourse, rational debate and consensus in creating understanding; Burkhard extends Habermas’s theories by applying them to organizations and looks at trust issues between organizations and their publics; Bourdieu deals with power and who gets to impose their point of view on others; Foucault’s ideas on discursive practices inform from a social structural dimension; Beck addresses risk in dialog; Weber brings ideas of charisma and domination to strategic communications; Mahew looks at persuasion; Luhmann focuses on how organizations create legitimacy; Benoit adds value with ideas on crisis communications and image restoration;  Putnam addressed issues of corporate reputation and corporate social responsibility by highlighting the benefits of community building, the development of social capital and the benefits to organizations of these efforts in a crisis; Dorothy Smith’s feminist approach suggested the validity of gender as an issue to use when viewing strategic communication; Spivak ‘post-colonialist perspective suggests that there is no such thing as neutral communication, from a there are dominant discourses and quiet others that impact messaging.

From a practical standpoint, strategic communication is a field of tactics.  One of our key learnings in this class was to get involved with social media.  Social media, and Twitter specifically, is a relatively new tool that we explored and which I have added to my toolbox of strategic communications mediums and methods.

I initially struggled with how and why to "use" Twitter.  I was unsure of what my ultimate motivation for using Twitter would be - tweeting about personal or class-related things interests certain people and creates a different sense of who I am than if my tweets are all about job hunting tips or social media how-to's.  It took me until after the semester was over to find my strategic use for Twitter and social media; I now use it to share what I believe is valuable information about using social media effectively. I tweet, retweet and follow people (people who convey knowledge in business, social media, and who strike me as thought leaders in areas I'm interested in) with purpose as I work to develop my brand.  As a result of this course I recognize that I will have to use a variety of communications tools to build my credibility and flesh out my new workplace identity. 

As I have also discovered in my use of social media, a focus on content is extremely important.  All of the clever branding ideas will come to nothing if no one is interested in what I say.  The quality of a message and its purposeful direction to appropriate stakeholders is foundational in the quest for communication that resonates.

In summary, it is the combination of message, medium and targeted delivery that will advance the mission of strategic communication.

Friday, January 21, 2011

COM 602 Research Proseminar

An overview of communications theory provided a framework for the course, and really for my overall Masters program.  

Communication is a process of shared meaning, where individuals create meaning through communication with others, resulting in a reality that is constructed from social interaction and is therefore constantly in flux and subject to change (social constructionism).  Understanding the context in which communication exists today was the beginning for my exploration into a communications research topic.

I discovered that I am interested in multigenerational issues in communication.  I narrowed my focus so that my research looked at the generationally diverse workplace in a rapidly changing world.  Employees must adapt and learn new skills in this highly competitive environment, and thus training emerged for me as being critical to the success of workers, organizations and even entire economies.  I found that in order to study the impact of training and its effectiveness, it would be important to discover the meanings made by the workers actually involved in a training program.    As a result of my research and paper writing, I was able to better understand the topic and issues surrounding generational differences.

From a process standpoint, as I worked on my research paper, I found I was informed on structural elements of research and writing.  I can now identify and locate academic research on a particular topic, make sense of existing research studies, and have a general understanding of quantitative and qualitative research methodologies including their respective validity and reliability measures.

In addition, I was able to acquire knowledge through academic research, and was able apply theory to my project.  I used an interpretive, social constructionist perspective in creating my paper.  I felt that I investigated my topic using all of the following thought traditions in small ways: positivist (cause and effect), systems (holistic, societal impact), interpretive (attempts at meaning), and critical (outcomes from struggle, conflict) traditions. 

My written assignments for the class are available for you to read below.

Capstone - Making Sense of my Communications Program


My name is Liz Horgan, and I expect to earn a Masters Degree in Organizational and Strategic Communications from the Knight School of Communications at Queens University of Charlotte in May, 2011.

I took the following courses:

Three Core Requirements:

COMM 602 Research Proseminar - Fall, 2009 with Dr. Kim Gregory
COMM 614 Ethical Issues in Communication - Fall, 2010 with Dr. Leane Pupchek
COMM 675 Capstone Seminar in Communication - Spring, 2011 with Dr. Kim Gregory (in process)


Strategic Track - Required

COMM 605 - Integrated Strategic Communication: Analysis and Theory - Spring, 2010 with Dr. John McArthur

2 Strategic Communications Electives

COMM 612 Persuasion - Fall, 2009 with Dr Leanne Pupchek
COMM 626 Best Practices in Strategic Communications - Summer, 2010 with Dr. Leanne Pupchek

plus 6 Electives

COMM 615 Interpersonal Communication in the Workplace - Spring, 2010 with Dr. Leanne Pupchek
COMM 628 Leadership and Communication - Summer, 2010 with Dr. Kristen Johnson
COMM 633 Strategic Crisis and Issues Management - Summer, 2010 with Larry Grayson
COMM 635 Organizational and Employee Identity - Summer, 2009 with Dr. Kim Gregory
ODEV 640 Introduction to Coaching - Fall, 2010 with Dr. John Bennett
ODEV 645 Advanced Coaching - Spring, 2010 with Dr. John Bennett